Virginia follows the contributory negligence rule. Under this rule, if an injured person’s own negligence helped cause their injuries, they may be barred from recovering compensation from the other party, even if the other party was mostly at fault. But an accusation of fault isn’t the same as proven fault. The other side generally has to prove that your negligence actually contributed to your injuries, and certain exceptions may still allow recovery.
At Deering Hedrick, P.C., our attorneys help injured people in Virginia Beach and throughout Hampton Roads understand how fault rules apply to their claims. If an insurance company is blaming you for an accident, don’t assume you have no case. Call (757) 383-6848 for a consultation.
Yes. Virginia follows contributory negligence for most negligence-based personal injury claims. If your own negligence was a proximate cause of your injuries, it generally bars recovery from another negligent party, subject to limited exceptions.
Most states use some form of comparative negligence instead. Here’s how the systems compare:
| Fault System | How It Works | Example: You’re 10% at Fault |
| Contributory negligence (Virginia) | Your proven negligence that contributed to the injury generally bars recovery | You may recover nothing |
| Pure comparative negligence | Recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault | You recover 90% of your damages |
| Modified comparative negligence | Recovery is reduced by your fault, but barred if your fault reaches a set threshold, often 50% or 51% | You recover 90% of your damages |
When a defendant raises contributory negligence as a defense, the defendant generally must prove, by the greater weight of the evidence, that you were negligent and that your negligence was a proximate cause of your injuries. Being careless in some unrelated way isn’t enough. A traffic violation alone does not resolve the contributory negligence question. The defense must also establish that the negligent conduct was a proximate cause of your injuries.
Strong evidence can help show what really happened, including:
Facing a dispute over fault? Call Deering Hedrick, P.C. at (757) 383-6848 for a free personal injury consultation.
Fault disputes look different depending on the type of accident.
In vehicle crashes, insurers may argue that the injured driver was speeding, distracted, following too closely, or failed to yield. Motorcyclists may face arguments about lane position or visibility. Rideshare claims can also involve disputes over which driver caused the crash and which insurance applies.
In pedestrian cases, the defense may claim the injured person crossed outside a crosswalk, was distracted, or entered the road unexpectedly.
In slip and fall cases, property owners often argue that the hazard was open and obvious or that the injured person wasn’t watching where they were going. These arguments can be challenged with evidence about lighting, warnings, conditions, and how the injury occurred.
Yes. While the rule is strict, it isn’t absolute.
The last clear chance doctrine may allow recovery despite an injured person’s negligence in limited circumstances. Virginia distinguishes between someone who is physically unable to escape danger and someone who could escape but is unaware of the danger.
In the first situation, the defendant must have seen, or should have seen, the person and recognized the danger. In the second, the defendant must actually have seen the person and recognized, or should have recognized, the danger.
In either situation, the defendant must have had enough time to avoid the harm by using reasonable care but failed to do so.
Virginia Code § 8.01-58 applies to certain railroad-employee injury claims, not ordinary car accident, pedestrian, or premises liability claims. For covered railroad-employee claims, an employee’s contributory negligence reduces damages proportionally rather than barring recovery.
If an insurance adjuster suggests you were at fault:
Fault disputes can also affect uninsured motorist claims.
A personal injury lawyer can investigate the accident, gather evidence, interview witnesses, and work with experts to show how the accident happened. An attorney can also evaluate whether exceptions like last clear chance may apply and challenge weak arguments about your conduct. If your case goes to court, your attorney can present the evidence to a judge or jury. Our article on how personal injury cases work in Virginia explains the process.
If an insurance company says you contributed to your injuries, do not assume that ends your claim. Deering Hedrick, P.C. can review the facts, explain how Virginia’s contributory negligence rule may apply, and discuss your options. Call (757) 383-6848 for a free personal injury consultation.